The Direct Answer: Does Retaking Replace or Average?
Retaking a class replaces the original grade in your GPA at schools with grade replacement or academic forgiveness policies. At schools without these policies, both grades remain and the GPA uses the average of all attempts.
Grade replacement means the original grade is removed from the GPA calculation and replaced with the new grade. Grade forgiveness means the original grade is forgiven (removed from GPA calculation) and replaced. Both terms describe the same outcome for GPA purposes: only the most recent attempt counts in GPA.
Grade averaging means both grades appear on the transcript and both contribute quality points and credit hours to the GPA calculation. A student who earns a D (1.0) and then retakes the course for an A (4.0) ends up with an average of 2.5 for those credit hours in GPA calculation. The GPA benefit of retaking is significantly reduced compared to grade replacement.
Both policies show the repeated course on the transcript. Grade replacement removes the original grade's contribution to GPA but the original attempt still appears as a notation on the transcript, often marked as excluded or repeated. The course appears twice; only one contributes to GPA.
Worked Example: Grade Replacement vs. Grade Averaging
A student with a 3.0 GPA over 60 credit hours who earns a D in a 3-credit course and then retakes it for an A will see different GPA outcomes depending on which policy applies.
Under Grade Replacement
The D (1.0 quality points × 3 credits = 3 quality points) is removed from the GPA. The A (4.0 quality points × 3 credits = 12 quality points) replaces it. Starting GPA: 3.0 over 60 credits = 180 total quality points. After replacement: (180 - 3 + 12) / 60 = 189 / 60 = 3.15. The student gains 0.15 GPA points from the retake.
Under Grade Averaging
Both attempts count. The student now has 63 credit hours and 192 quality points (180 original + 3 from D + 12 from A minus the original course's 3 quality points... actually: original 60 credits contributing 180 points, plus D at 3 = 183, plus A at 12 more = 195, over 66 total credits). Recalculating: original 60 credits = 180 quality points. Add D: 63 credits, 183 quality points (3.0 base GPA intact since the D was the new course). Then add A retake: 66 credits, 195 quality points. GPA = 195 / 66 = 2.95.
Under grade averaging, the extra credit hours from both attempts dilute the GPA because the combined quality points (D + A = 1.0 + 4.0 = 5.0 across 6 credit hours = 2.5 average) drag down a 3.0 baseline. Grade replacement is always more beneficial to GPA than grade averaging for any retake of a below-average grade.
How LSAC and AMCAS Handle Retaken Courses
The Law School Admission Council (LSAC) and American Medical College Application Service (AMCAS) both count all undergraduate course attempts in their GPA recalculations, ignoring whatever replacement or forgiveness policy your undergraduate school applied.
LSAC recalculates GPA on a 4.33 scale using all graded undergraduate coursework. A course retaken three times appears as three separate entries. Law school applicants who retook courses after receiving grade forgiveness at their undergraduate institution will find their LSAC GPA lower than their official transcript GPA. The retake still benefits you because an A replaces an F in quality points, but both attempts count.
AMCAS follows the same approach. Every undergraduate course attempt appears in the AMCAS GPA, including courses for which your school granted forgiveness. A pre-medical student who failed organic chemistry, received forgiveness, and retook for an A will still show both grades in the AMCAS science GPA. The original F lowers the AMCAS science GPA even if the school transcript shows only the A.
Medical and law school applicants should calculate their LSAC and AMCAS GPAs separately from their official transcript GPA before applying. Many pre-med and pre-law advisors use AMCAS and LSAC calculation tools for this exact reason. A student with an official 3.6 GPA who received forgiveness on two F grades in early college may have a 3.3 AMCAS GPA.
Grade Forgiveness Program Rules by Institution Type
Grade forgiveness programs exist at most four-year public universities and community colleges. Policies vary significantly by school on how many courses qualify, whether the program is automatic or requires petition, and what grade threshold triggers eligibility.
| Policy Feature | Common Range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Max courses eligible | 1 to 5 courses | Most schools cap at 3 courses lifetime |
| Grade threshold | D or F | Some schools allow forgiveness of any C grade or below |
| Same course only | Yes, at most schools | Must retake the identical course, not an equivalent |
| Time limit | None to 5 years | Some programs require retake within 3 years |
| Application required | Usually yes | Often a registrar petition before or after retake |
Academic fresh start or renewal programs differ from standard forgiveness. Academic renewal forgives all grades from a defined prior period (often the first 1 to 2 years) for students who re-enroll after a 3 to 5 year absence. Renewed grades may still appear on official transcripts sent to graduate schools and professional school application services.
When Retaking a Course Makes Strategic Sense
Retaking a course makes the strongest strategic case when your school offers grade replacement for the specific grade, when the course is in your major or a prerequisite chain, and when the GPA improvement meaningfully affects your application or academic standing.
A student with a 2.8 GPA applying to competitive nursing programs who has a D in anatomy and physiology should retake the course regardless of grade replacement policy because nursing program admissions look at prerequisite course grades directly. A 4.0 in anatomy on a second attempt can outweigh an institutional GPA that still shows the D from the first attempt.
Retaking a course that will not receive grade replacement for a marginal GPA improvement (e.g., raising a C to a B adds only 1 quality point per credit hour) may not justify the cost in time and tuition compared to earning high grades in new courses. New courses at 4.0 add more total quality points when you have many credits left to earn.
Consulting your registrar and academic advisor before retaking any course confirms the specific policy at your institution, the forgiveness application deadline, and whether the original grade will affect financial aid satisfactory academic progress calculations.
More GPA Guides
Calculate your GPA now — free, no signup
GPA Calculator →